Friday, 21 March 2008

Can it be true?

There's all sorts of speculation in the press at the moment that, following a meeting yesterday apparently between former skipper and legend Martin Johnson and England's Director of Elite Rugby Rob Andrew, Johnno is to be appointed as England Team Manager to work alongside head coach Brian Ashton.

I'm not so sure. Don't get me wrong, I'd love it, just love it (to quote Kevin Keegan) if Johnno was to come on board - but if he were to accept a role he would have to be in overall charge of the England coaching and management set-up. There's just no point in him just being there as some sort of front-of-house figurehead.

So, if Johnno is appointed, where does that leave the ageing head coach? Ashton has already gone on record as saying he doesn't want a manager who will want to be involved in rugby decisions and has apparently sounded out another former England skipper (albeit a useless one), Phil De Glanville, for the role. Ashton, it seems, wants someone to handle organisational matters plus relations with the RFU and the media - a role Johnson, one would imagine (and hope), simply wouldn't contemplate.

My theory is this...having recommended that each of the current England coaching team retain their respective positions following the extensive post-World Cup review, Rob Andrew can't very well turn round and now admit that he got this decision badly wrong as his own position would then almost be untenable. However, by giving Johnson the England Team Manager job (a role that Ashton had requested be filled), the responsibility for retaining or firing the coaching team can be passed to the former skipper, thus severely undermining Ashton's position to an extent that the beleaguered head coach may find he has no option but to resign - therefore satisfying the hawks within the RFU who see Ashton as a lame duck whilst at the same time allowing Andrew to save his own bacon.

Of course, this being the RFU, there's always a chance that there's absolutely nothing in this, that the status quo will prevail and that it will be business as usual until the next humiliating defeat (almost inevitably a record defeat to New Zealand in June).


Anonymous said...

This is a shocking decision. Here is a guy who doesn’t coach rugby at any level and we now want to make him head coach!

How does that make any sense?

He quit international rugby 5 years ago and retired from club rugby in 2005, as a hero for what he achieved on the pitch. And rightly so he helped Leicester and England win a hell of a lot, but that was a player doing what he did best playing! Not picking the side or setting up tactics. He was a great motivator, he had and still does have a lot of respect form the players. Bringing him into the coaching set up is a waste of time and money (as it’s the RFU a lot of money), he’s going to be chronically out of his depth, then as soon as we lose to the All Blacks in the summer ever kev-ball playing twit that watches rugby once ever 4 years and owns a 2003 England shirt will be calling for him to be the man in charge.

If you want a ex-player in charge lets make sure he has some coaching experience. I’m gonging out on a limb, here but I think that’s important if you want to be a head COACH of a country.

Total Flanker said...

Well, firstly as far as I can see no decision has yet been made and, secondly, if Johnson was appointed as a manager with the power to pick his own coaching team I wouldn't bet against him doing an excellent job. He knows the game, is by no means stupid, wouldn't accept the role lightly and wouldn't take on any coaching responsibilities himself. His selectorial and motivational abilities are better than Ashton's (they couldn't be worse, let's face it). I have absolutely no problem at all with his appointment so long as the role is very clearly defined and isn't the usual RFU fudge.

Home Theater said...

Hello. This post is likeable, and your blog is very interesting, congratulations :-). I will add in my blogroll =). If possible gives a last there on my blog, it is about the Home Theater, I hope you enjoy. The address is A hug.